Welcome to The Fingers Weekender, a Sunday digest exclusively for paying Friends of Fingers featuring the independent journalism about drinking in America you love, optimized for hungover scrolling. In today’s edition:

  • Molson Coors’ now-former CCO got a golden parachute;

  • Ste. Michelle Wine Estates got a wage-theft class-action suit;

  • DISCUS got big mad at Trump again;

  • The bev-alc industry got more bad news about crossfading;

And much more. As ever, if someone forwarded this to you, buy a subscription to get next Sunday’s edition straight in your inbox.

logo

The Weekender is only for paid subscribers.

Friends of Fingers love this independent coverage and commentary about drinking in America. You will too. Buy a subscription today at a sweet discount!

Upgrade

Already a subscriber? Sign in

Upgrade to read the rest of this Weekender, plus:

  • Weekly columns about drinking in America
  • Weekenders full of industry news & analysis
  • Commenting privileges, archive access, and more

Reply

Avatar

or to participate

Avatar

Emma S1 year ago

On the Siebel announcement, what I found most fascinating (and I didn't know this but maybe it was more common knowledge among beer industry people) was that Siebel has been owned by Lallemand since 2000! That's like the brewing equivalent of Stanford's Computer Science Department being owned by Intel or Nvidia! It raises the question to me about how objective can their education really be when owned by a private company? I don't mean this to be a criticism of the quality of the education or the staff, but Lallemand is surely going to be prioritizing their products, and I am sure that Lallemand's rivals (e.g. Lesaffre etc) are going to steer clear of any collaborations or research funding donations. I also don't think you can completely blame Trump for the move to Montreal, this appears to me to be as much of a move by Lallemand to consolidate fermentation capacity/resources in one location in response to Lesaffre's massive $$$ into their R&D capacity in Lille.

Avatar

Emma S1 year ago

It also makes me think about how the push among certain universities to increasingly teach "practical" skills has really decimated certain skill-specific trade schools like Siebel particularly among the American student population. UC Davis (and the wine education programs in general) have actually been lucky in that they have traditionally been associated with universities in the USA and not left to fend for themselves financially...

Avatar

Dave Infante1 year ago

Is that true? I don't know much about the dynamic between trade schools and four-year university. I imagine it's sorta trade-specific? Eg., I can't imagine that degree-issuing programs are horning in on like... pipefitting schools' student bases. Right? (Or maybe they are, which would be fascinating!)

Avatar

Emma S1 year ago

I can't speak to pipefitter schools, but I do know that fermentation science programs/degrees were popping up all over the place about 15-20 years ago (e.g. Colorado State, Central Washington, Appalachian State University) and some universities also offer certificate programs in brewing/fermentation science. I wonder (although I don't have any data on this so take it with a grain of salt) some students who might have considered Siebel might have opted for other programs.

Avatar

Emma S1 year ago

Also separate country, but when Roseworthy Agricultural College--the site of the Australian wine industry's most famous training program--merged with the University of Adelaide in the 1990s one of the reasons for the merger from what I was told was to make the agricultural programs more "competitive" nationally by affiliating them with a university. In retrospect, it also probably saved Viticulture and (O)enology as a separate department/discipline over there, I doubt they would have survived otherwise. Anyway, to tie it back to Siebel, I'm sure there is a fascinating story behind why Lallemand decided to invest!

Avatar

Dave Infante1 year ago

Yeah that tension is not uncommon among trade-specific educational institutions due to the funding restraints. I have not encountered any chatter (and certainly not any formal complaints) from past or present Siebel students alleging untoward corporate meddling in the curriculum, but even if nobody's talking about it, it doesn't mean it's not happening. Hard to say, maybe some folks closer to the school will chime in on that!

Avatar

Dave Infante1 year ago

Here's a related comment from Matt Strickland of Iron City Distilling via LinkedIn:

"This is great Dave. Just a quick take as one of their faculty members. (I've been working for them in some capacity on their distilling courses since 2019.) I noticed in the comments on your page there are/were some concerns about Lallemand's ownership and potential bias in the education. While I can't speak to the brewing side of things, I can say that I just taught a week-long course on distilling operations out there back in October and discussed a lot about fermentation, often promoting other yeast company's products and at no point did anyone from Lallemand step in to stop me. In my experience, they really have been hands-off with many of Siebel's courses. (The same cannot be said for some of their other educational endeavors such as The Alcohol School, which is not a criticism but simply a statement of their branded involvement.)"

Avatar

Emma S1 year ago

This is great thank you, and good to hear perspectives from people who have worked there! Hopefully there won't be too much of a change in that regard with the move to Montreal