In late January, a few days before the United States’ shitposter-in-chief kicked off his big dumb trade war in earnest, I filed a column here at Fingers about a pair of non-tariff-related wine-industry storylines, highlighted in the then-just-released Silicon Valley Bank State of The Industry report, that are in a bit of tension with one another. On one hand, SVB executive vice-president and founding author Rob McMillan argued that “neo-Prohibitionists” were “using marketing tools disguised as scientific studies, cherry-picking data, and changing the definition of health measurements.” On the other, he noted that wine-based ready-to-drinks (RTDs) grew 29.3% year-over-year. “RTDs are growing like a rocketship, still,” he said in a video unpacking the findings of the most recent edition of his two-and-a-half-decades-running report.

“I don’t want to hear another fucking word about ‘neo-Prohibition’ until every winemaker in America has tried and failed to stand up an RTD brand,” is how I synthesized those two ideas at the time. Admittedly, a little flip! As is often the case, my colleague Kate Bernot, longtime beverage-alcohol journalist and lead analyst at Sightlines, found a way to make a similar case point with a whole lot more grace than your fearless Fingers editor is able to muster.

“I urge the wine industry to lay down its arms in this battle,” she wrote a couple weeks ago on LinkedIn, a professional platform, responding to yet another trade-led effort at debunking the allegedly shoddy science of Large Abstinence. “Arguing for the health benefits of alcohol will always be fraught, and heart health is not what draws most consumers—certainly not young ones—to the wine category.” She would know, having done a bunch of reportage for this February 2025 VinePair feature on this, and doing deep-dive analyses at Sightlines on an ongoing basis. I called her up earlier this week to expand on her plea, which I think is correct, and to chat through the stuff that is working for winemakers. Including RTDs, yes, but not limited to them. Below is an edited and condensed transcript of our conversation.

logo

Subscribe to Fingers to read the rest.

Become a paying subscriber of Fingers to get access to this post and other subscriber-only content.

Upgrade

Already a subscriber? Sign in

A subscription gets you:

Reply

Avatar

or to participate

Avatar

reeeegan m1 year ago

God I want to print out this interview and paste it all over wine country. That said, I think you’re actually proving that winemakers are doing the thing they’re supposed to be doing in the examples you’re talking about — it’s just taking time, because wine is slow. It’s always been slow. Ask any Boomer about Blue Nun or Riunite and they’ll describe something almost identical to the Pizza Wine and Buzzwhateverthefuck examples you both referenced.

That stuff is coming for this new generation — Gratsi, boxed Lambrusco, etc. It’s happening. But what’s missing right now is: what is the higher end of wine (say, $30 and up) even talking about? How is it capturing hearts and minds? That’s the real existential crisis. That, and the fact that we're staring a flood of these Boomer WealthFucking Estates trying to sell out before the market drops out because no one cares about the wines they're making because it was always only about vanity.

Avatar

Kate Bernot1 year ago

Semi-related: Can someone explain why a brand called Wineslut costs $28 at my local grocery store?

Avatar

Dave InfanteAuthor1 year ago

Forget occasion-based marketing, say hello to o-SLAY-sion-based marketing!!!

(sorry, sorry, I'm trying to delete it)

Avatar

Dave InfanteAuthor1 year ago

You can only do that if you cut the bottom into little pull-tabs that say "FINGERS.EMAIL/SUBSCRIBE", like flyers for guitar lessons used to have for phone numbers with no area codes. God I'm getting old.

But seriously, glad you enjoyed the interview. Kate is so smart on this stuff. And you're right, there are green shoots! And that's good! But "wine is slow" is only an acceptable explanation for the reluctance if the wine industry can afford to be slow. The aggregate sales figures and constant kvetching suggest otherwise! If a winery can make money not pivoting to BuzzBallz (or whatever), I don't think they should! But if they're struggling, they need to find new markets to sell to and new products to sell. That's a good place to put their energy, I think. It's certainly a better place than like... carping on about the nEo-PrOhIbItIoNiStS, or whatever. Who even knows if we're doing USDA guidelines anymore!

Avatar

reeeegan m1 year ago

Fair enough, it's just easier to complain about that stuff than taking that last bit of dignity out back and shooting in the brain. Things have slowed down but I honestly don't think it's about finding new markets, per se, it is just clicking things into place for the new generations. I have a very boring theory about how "Fine Wine" is just so fragmented between the olds, the nerds, the political hellbent and the naturalists that everyone's bored of their corners of wine and it's not fun anymore. I think that is going to change though, especially once people realise how futile all this health hacking is and do like their parents did: shelve the Jane Fonda tapes for some good ol' Merlot....